Living in Northern Cyprus

Orams lose Cyprus property court case

In: Legal Advice| News| Property

20 Jan 2010

The high profile court case between a British couple who own a villa in Northern Cyprus and the original Greek Cypriot owner of the land Meletios Apostolides ended yesterday with a European court upholding an original judgement made in a Republic of Cyprus court in favour of Mr Apostolides.

The ruling means David and Linda Oram must now demolish the beautiful Lapta villa built with their life savings and pay Apostolides compensation (effectively ground rent) for the time they have occupied the land.

The landmark decision could have an impact on Greek Cypriot’s disputing ownership of land in Northern Cyprus and that could be bad news for the estimated 1400 owners in a similar situation to the Orams. Although the decision was made in a European court, it is not clear how the ruling will be enforced in Turkish controlled Northern Cyprus.

In 1974 after many years of unrest between Turkey and Greece, Turkish troops intervened after after a political coup took place within then Greek controlled Government of Cyprus. This led to many land owners being displaced from the north and relocating to the south. Many people believe the Oram’s have been used as political pawns between the Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot sides in an attempt to add weight to their bargaining positions in the unification talks currently being held.

Greek Cypriot president Demetris Christofias and his Turkish counter-part Mehmet Ali Talat have been meeting regularly for over a year and recently intensified to regular twice weekly sessions in an attempt to find a solution. One of the main stumbling blocks between the two sides in the unification talks has been resolving the issue of property and land rights on the island. In addition to the Greek Cypriots there are also Turkish Cypriots who owned land in the south now occupied. Much of Larnaca airport is built on Turkish Cypriot owned land.

For those people with property in Northern Cyprus with ‘exchange deeds’ the advice is don’t panic, each case must be heard on it’s own merit and many Greek Cypriots have no wish to return to their land. If a solution can be found between the two sides it is thought a compensation package would be available to land owners with a claim.
Although the Orams cannot appeal on the decision there will be could more twists and turns to their story yet.

Stay up to date with Northern Cyprus latest news, events, competitions and articles from Lincguide, by subscribing to our free service. Click here to activate

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

12 Responses to Orams lose Cyprus property court case

Avatar

Sibel Hodge

January 20th, 2010 at 11:35 am

It will be interesting to see exactly how they can comply with the judgement in TRNC. The Orams, sadly, have been the victims of a political witch hunt. This case should have gone through the Property Commission set up by Turkey. I think this will spell the end to the Cyprus Talks. The EU are responsible for this by letting an undevided island join the EU in the first place. Unfortunately, the rest of the world seems to forget the real issues surrounding the "Cyprus Problem." My thoughts go out to the Orams.

Avatar

Peter Graham

January 20th, 2010 at 11:41 am

Thanks for the comments Sibel, I think there is more to the unification talks than just the Orams case but it certainly wont help things.

My sympathies go to the Orams too, they have been through alot.

Avatar

Alex

January 20th, 2010 at 11:55 am

And my sympathies go to ALL displaced cypriots… they REALLY have been through a lot in the past AND the present

Avatar

Peter Graham

January 20th, 2010 at 12:08 pm

I agree with you too Alex, alot of people have suffered from the conflict in Cyprus on both sides.
It is time to move on and make sure history is not repeated.

join our facebook page
http://www.facebook.com/onecyprus

Avatar

Alex

January 20th, 2010 at 12:23 pm

I will do so. Thank you for the invite

Avatar

colin21

January 20th, 2010 at 2:55 pm

If Apostolides cannot get the ruling enforced in the TRNC, will he then go back to the UK courts to seek compensation by seizing the Orams' assets in the UK?

Avatar

GHURKA

January 20th, 2010 at 3:47 pm

GAU have built a dormitory block in Edremit on ex-Greek Church land, they are proposing to build a University in Canterbury Uk -what will they do? Its time for Talat to close talks its impossible to deal with the South.

Avatar

Luke

January 20th, 2010 at 3:50 pm

Our neighbours, refugees from the north of Cyprus when it was invaded and occupied in 1974, live in property that is Turkish Cypriot owned in Larnaka. However, they are on permanent 3 month notice to vacate when the Turkish Cypriot owners move to the ROC to reclaim their property. They have willingly spent their own money to renovate/maintain the property, yet know they have no legal claim to it. A small business in the same town is utilising Turkish Cypriot owned land – for which the business pays a monthly rent to the Guardian of Turkish Cypriot property. That is kept in an account for the rightful owner.

Appropriation of land for 'the common good' is a different issue. As I'm sure UK landowners who have had their land force-purchased by the British government for eg expansion of the British motorway network would tell you.

What is clear is that there are 'moral' and 'immoral' ways of dealing with these situations. No-one wants to be homeless, or to lose land and property their families have owned for generations. Just ask any Palestinian who has lost farmland, businesses, houses etc.

Avatar

Sibel Hodge

January 21st, 2010 at 3:21 pm

The lawyer for Apostolides has now stated they will be suing tourists for staying in the Dome hotel! http://www.northcyprusforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=4...
Unbelievable. This could be yet another reason that the “Cyprus talks” are doomed to failure.

Avatar

Emma

January 21st, 2010 at 9:03 pm

Sorry to the Orams, they have been the victims of a political witch hunt. How can you have a country half EU and not the other. So on the south they are prepared to hand over the property to the rightful owners. What about the land they have built on that did not belong to them, do not believe everything you read, this Cyprus situation will never get sorted out, if they want one side EU and not the other, close the borders again

Avatar

Marie B

January 31st, 2010 at 10:18 pm

It is the inequalities that seem to be a sticking point. All that has been mentioned above about property should have been left until the talks were finished and some kind of conclusion reached. But the unfairness goes alongside the inequality. The Greek Cypriots have issued a list of hotels formerly owned by GC;s or built on land belonging to GC's and telling travel companies not to put people in there. I know for a fact that Onar Village is one of those, built in 1991 on 27 donums of 'exchange large' and half way up a mountain. The owners of the hotel used to have one thousand donum in the south which has bene built on. Why would the GC's want back a mountain side? Why not accept that sometimes it is 'fair exchange' and also accept that by far the larger number of the populationon both sides have rebuilt their lives to the best of their ability and done quite well. Including, Mr Apostolides, who is using the Orams to score points. Why should he want one tenth of the former family land which does not even contain the 'ancestral home'. Let's hope rthe leaders can at least come up with some proper starting points, and let's hope the Orams do NOT get persued in U.K for what is their 'ancestral home'

Avatar

pete

February 1st, 2010 at 10:14 am

Thanks for the comment Maire, it will be interesting to see what the UN ambassodor will do to help the current talks… he is due in Cyprus today,

Comment Form

Living in Northern Cyprus

Blog Categories

A photo on Flickr

Blog Archive

Talks in Cyprus
Pink Floyd in Cyprus
on Facebook
Follow Lincguide on Twitter