Legal Questions – AnsweredIn: Advice|Legal Advice 22 Apr 2009
1 2 In line with this directive, many vendors are therefore now invoicing their clients for VAT, which is currently 5% of the purchase price of the property, on completion of the construction. Many people have criticised this new directive by the Tax Office because they fear that if the VAT is paid by a purchaser to a construction company on completion, the construction company may not account to the Tax Office for it. On transfer of title, the Tax Office requires proof that the VAT has been paid before it will allow transfer of title to take place. If the construction company has not paid this money to the Tax Office, the purchaser may not be able to take title without this being paid. Some pressure groups are lobbying the Government to try to change this practice so that VAT can be paid directly by the purchasers to the Tax Office on completion of the property instead of to the construction company to ensure that there is no risk of the construction company failing to account to the Tax Office for the VAT. However, this is not possible at present. There is no legal requirement on the vendor to keep this money in a separate account. Therefore, to protect our clients, we are currently advising our clients only to pay VAT to the construction company in return for an official invoice (known as a ‘fatura’ in Turkish) from the construction company. This should bear the stamp of the Tax Office on it and should state the amount paid. Once a construction company has issued an official invoice, it must account for that money to the Tax Office. The invoice should be retained by the purchaser or their lawyer to produce to the Tax Office on transfer of title. The Tax Office has confirmed that production of this invoice will be sufficient for transfer of title to prove that the VAT has been paid.” 3 If the association is to be formed by non-TRNC citizens or if any non-TRNC citizen is to be a member of the association, they must first obtain permission from the Council of Ministers by submitting an application. Similarly if the association exists abroad and wishes to register in the TRNC, it must submit an application to the Council of Ministers. This is can be a lengthy process, so most associations are usually formed with TRNC citizens as their members. You must complete an application form which can be obtained from the District Office and must produce a Constitution or Articles which contains information such as the name, address and purpose of the association, the names and addresses of the members, how members are accepted and removed, how the association is to be run, how meetings are to be held and decisions made, the powers and authorities of the association and its members etc. Most lawyers will be able to draft a suitable constitution for an association. The association must pay a fee to the Association Support Fund which is currently 1/10th of the minimum wage. The receipt for this must be produced to the District Office with 2 copies of the constitution and a list of all of the members with their signatures, names, addresses and professions. 4 This involves taking the testator with the will to the Probate Registrar. The Probate Registrar checks the will to ensure the above formalities have been complied with and checks the identity of the testator. This reduces the risk of anyone contesting the will in the future on the ground that it was a forgery or that the relevant formalities had not been complied with. If the will is signed outside of the country but states that it covers property in the TRNC, providing the above formalities have been complied with, it will be valid. However, in the event of death, proving the will can more difficult. Sometimes, as part of the probate procedure, the witnesses to the will are required to attend court or sign documents. This may be complicated if they live abroad. Further, the Probate Registrar at the District Court will not accept the registration of wills signed outside of the country. Therefore you cannot advantage of the benefit of lodging the will with the Probate Registrar as outlined above and the risk that the validity of the will could be contested by any person entitled under the estate is increased. Alternatively, it is possible, if you leave a will in the UK covering your property in Northern Cyprus, in the event of your death, to complete the probate work in the UK and then, once the Grant of Probate has been issued in the UK, to apply to the courts here for the Grant of Probate to be re-sealed and re-validated for use in the TRNC so that the terms of the Grant of Probate and the will can be applied to the estate here. However, this can be a lengthy process and the UK Grant of Probate must be obtained and certified by the TRNC consulate in London together with various other original documents. In my experience, the simplest way to ensure that your assets are protected and to avoid doubt about the validity of the will, is to prepare and sign your will with a lawyer in the TRNC and lodge it with the Probate Registrar at the District Court. This will should cover just your property in the TRNC and should be separate to any other wills you may have made in any other country covering your property in that country”. 5 There is no official policy by the Government that non-TRNC citizens cannot receive permission to purchase for pre-1974 title. However, there has been widespread speculation in the press that this is the case. This speculation has been generated by lawyers who claim that the purchase permit applications for their clients who are buying pre-1974 title property are either being rejected or delayed. The problem is that when an application for permission is refused, lawyers do not receive written confirmation of the refusal and do not receive any reasons for the refusal. It is very difficult, therefore, to establish exactly why a particular application has been refused. There have also been claims recently that some applications have been refused due to the proximity of the property to a military base. It is not always easy or possible to discover whether or not there is a military area in the vicinity of the property and lawyers cannot obtain a definitive answer to this question prior to submitting an application. The official stance of the Government all purchasers should obtain permission to purchase from the Council of Ministers before purchasing the property and before any monies are paid by the purchaser. However, due to the length of time permissions are taking to be processed (currently around 2 – 2 ½ years on average), purchasers find that following this advice is not practical. Many purchasers find that it is virtually impossible to find a vendor who is willing to wait for a purchaser to obtain purchase permission before concluding the sale. Purchasers who proceed on this basis must therefore accept that there is a risk attached to purchasing without obtaining permission from the Council of Ministers first and there is a small possibility that the permission to purchase could be refused. Few vendors are willing to refund the money to the purchaser in the event that the permission to purchase is refused claiming that this is something which is out of their hands. Many campaigners have criticised the current system and have tried to advocate the introduction of a new system where, during the initial stages of planning applications, sites are officially declared ‘suitable for non-citizens’ or ‘suitable only for TRNC citizens’ so that purchasers are aware before they buy. Alternatively, the procedure for granting permissions to purchase needs to be completely overhauled so that permissions can be granted within weeks rather than years to allow purchasers to obtain their permission to purchase before signing the Contract and making payment in line with the current Government advice. You could try to appeal against the decision, firstly by writing a letter to the Ministry of the Interior, or if this fails, by considering legal action in the High Administrative Court for judicial review of this decision. Litigation of this kind can be lengthy and expensive, but it might be worth considering sending a letter initially. If the rejection is due to a person reason relating to the application, could try applying again in a different name, for example, in the name of a friend or relative whom you know well and trust who could take title to the property on your behalf and hold it on trust for you. However, this will involve starting the process again from the beginning and therefore, it could take a further 2 – 2 ½ years before permission is granted. Legal fees would usually have to be paid again and there are risks associated with having the property in the name of another person, so careful advice would need to be sought. You could put the property into the name of a Turkish Cypriot friend or relative whom you know well and trust and who can hold the property on trust for you. This would be a simple procedure as the Turkish Cypriot would not require permission to purchase. You may have to pay some additional legal fees to your lawyer for your lawyer to arrange for the transfer. There are risks associated with having the property in the name of another person, so careful advice would need to be sought. Some law firms, such as ourselves, have a designated client trust company which has been incorporated specifically to hold property on trust for our clients in return for an initial subscription fee and an annual trustee fee. You could sell the property by assigning your rights under the Contract of Sale. This will require the signature of the landowner. A new piece of legislation has recently been passed by the Government which will allow non-citizens to own property on a long-term leasehold basis for 99 years. As the legislation is very new, it is not yet entirely clear what the procedure for this is, but it is an option which can be considered. 6 This depends on whether the transferor and the transferee are TRNC citizens or citizens of other countries and if they are citizens of other countries, whether they have the title deeds to the property or are still going through the process to obtain their permission to purchase. For citizens of other countries, where the title deed is in the name of the transferor and the transferee is also a non-TRNC citizen, the transferee must first apply for permission to purchase in the usual way and wait for this to be granted by the Council of Ministers. Once the permission has been granted, if the relationship is, as above, parent – child or grandparent – child or between spouses, the gift rate of tax will apply. Otherwise, the usual taxes payable on transfer of title will apply to the transferor and the transferee. If the transferor has not yet obtained the title deeds and is still going through the purchase permit process, the application can be amended so that the permission will be granted n the name of the transferee instead. This is a relatively simple process carried out by writing to the Government enclosing the passport, completed purchase permit application form (which your lawyer will provide) and police disclosure certificate for the transferee. However, as with all purchase permit applications, it can be some time before the application is granted. There is no charge levied by the Government for making this kind of change, but you may have to pay legal fees to your lawyer for submitting the amendment on your behalf. Unfortunately Naomi cannot reply to comments, Lincguide wishes to thank her for giving her time up to answer these questions. To keep up to date with news and information from Lincguide join our mailing list to recive our monthly updates > Related articles on Lincguide you may also be interested in:
Comment Form
|
11 Responses to Legal Questions – Answered
Avril Meacher
April 22nd, 2009 at 7:28 pm
Dear Naomi,
I found your replies very informative and written in a clear and concise manner.
Your information regarding VAT was of particular interest to me and my husband,
as we paid over our VAT 3 years ago but do not have a fatura from the tax office.
Keep up the good work, it is refreshing to know of someonewho will give up their time
to help people with their legal problems.
Pilgrim
April 22nd, 2009 at 7:57 pm
Pre74 answer was more general to any refusal of ptp, expected more bite. As pre74 turkish title is supposedly internationally recognised , I would have expected some reference to ECHR or at least possibilites of registration in ROC.
Maggie
April 23rd, 2009 at 6:27 am
Dear Naomi
Thank you for taking the time to answer our 'charity status' question. It is a very precise answer and now gives us a totally clear picture of the procedures involved.
Thanks again.
The question about wills was also informative as our solicitor charged a fortune to write wills for us that were a copy of our UK wills but did NOT take us to the probate office to have them lodged there. When a friends husband died it took an extremely long time for probate and I suspect her will had not been lodged either. Very informative replies.
Roy Phippard
April 23rd, 2009 at 9:39 am
Thank you Naomi – very helpful as always. Information given is so helpful and precise.
Sue
April 24th, 2009 at 7:43 am
Write your comment here…
Peter Graham
April 24th, 2009 at 9:04 am
Many thanks for your hard work Naomi, i know you have helped a lot of people.
John & Sandra Dear
April 24th, 2009 at 3:55 pm
There are 6 villas on our site. We mostly used different solicitors, and at present, 4 of us have received our Deeds, the other two are still waiting. The four who jhave deeds however have noted that the deeds are for the land only, and the villa is not shown. Could you tell us the best way to proceed, and if we need to wait for the other 2 to get their land deed, to enable us all to have house and land on the deeds. Thanks.
stewart
May 4th, 2009 at 12:17 pm
How will the recent adverse ruling against the ORAMS effect my apartment that was bought on Exchanged land?
Peter Graham
May 14th, 2009 at 7:13 am
Hi John & Sandra,
I will pass your questions on to Naomi.
Stay tuned for her next Q & A
offshoredi
May 21st, 2009 at 7:11 am
I own a penthouse apartment at Chelsey Village and have had problems with my roof leaking water when it rains heavily. Have asked the builder for the past 2 years to fix, they have come 3 times not once went up on the roof. I had to get an outside firm in to check the roof and they found broken roof tiles, which they fixed, they have been back to put felt down but the water is still getting under the tiles.
As the building is supposed to be guaranteed have I any come back with the builder as many times I have had to stay in as they said they would come and never appeared that is why I had to contact another firm as it was like a waterfall on my balcony when the rain was heave and I was scared the inside would get damp.
Diana Gove
Linda
June 29th, 2009 at 7:40 pm
We have took possesion of our villa 18 months ago, we still have not registered for permmission to purchase, as our lawyer tells us we cant apply until we have the land owners signature, one of our land owners is in canada, our builder keeps telling us he will be back to sign but nothing ever happens been waiting two years, could you please advise us.
Linda